Charmed and Dangerous - S4-E13
Character mistake: When Phoebe is describing to Cole the demon she saw in her premonition, she says on the good side of his face he had tribal markings, and Cole says, "Kinda like Belthazar," and Phoebe agrees. Belthazar has no markings like the ones on the demon's face.
Answer: "Hush, Hush, Hush" Paula Cole.