Favoritism - S5-E13
Continuity mistake: In 4-8 Mateo makes Amy a mushroom dish which she admits to being allergic to, but in this episode Amy eats a grilled cheese sandwich with a mushroom on top . (00:13:03)
Continuity mistake: When the team is in the men's room and Cheyenne shows her phone to Glen to show him that the app can't track them there, her phone is on its home screen. As soon as the shot changes, she is in the middle of scrolling through an app/website.
Chosen answer: He's just gained weight. It looks like he slowly started gaining more weight around 2006 or so. In "Kids in the Hall: Death Comes to Town" (2010) he's noticeably heavier than his younger days (he was on SNL 21 years ago). By the time he was in "Man Seeking Woman" he looks very similar to how he looks in "Superstore."
Bishop73