Corrected entry: Whenever something happens each Groundhog Day, everyone forgets it the next Groundhog Day (Same day, of course.) But the Groundhog Day that everyone has a party, after all the good things Phil does, like pumping up the old women's cars, everyone he helped remembers him.
Corrected entry: No matter how long Phil spends in his hotel, he always seems to meet Ned Ryerson at exactly the same spot on the road, whereas Ned ought to be long gone in some scenes and yet to appear in others.
Corrected entry: When Phil Connors is giving the now deceased street bum mouth to mouth in an effort to save him, he raises his head to take another breath and you can see the breath from the old man rising, even though he is supposed to be dead. And it can't be Phil's as it is rising.
Corrected entry: When the pickup truck smashes through the gate, you can see that its grill is already busted.
Correction: Viewing the frames, one at a time, shows prior to the gate crash, the grill is intact, and can be seen dropping when it impacts.
Corrected entry: Right after the scene where Bill Murray gets hit in the head with the shovel while talking on the phone, there is a shot outside the bar where Bill is inside drinking and it is night time. In the scene following, Bill is taking a shower for the first time. While Bill is in the cold shower, it is day time outside of the window but it should be night time because he hasn't woken up a 2nd time yet.
Correction: Just because they don't show him waking up doesn't mean he didn't. The movie shows plenty of days that were repeated and we don't see everything that he did each time.
Corrected entry: In the first scene at the bed and breakfast before Phil says "chance of departure." he is talking to the lady. At the end of this scene he picks up his cup of coffee. Yet when he says his lines seconds later, the coffee cup is gone and he is putting on his coat. (00:09:55)
Correction: He sets the coffee down to put on his coat, just like any other normal person would do, so as not to spill it.
Corrected entry: When Phil is driving Ralph's car on the railroad tracks, if he were on the same track as the train, he would not have made it since he had not turned off the tracks until the train was up to him.
Correction: It's tricky to judge how far away objects are from the outer dimensions of a vehicle you're sitting in. This is why there are so many scrapes and bumps in parking lots, etc. The POV was from inside the car at this moment, so we can't know for sure exactly how close the train was.
Corrected entry: It is clear that Phil arrives at Gobbler's Nob at a slightly different time each day, some days earlier, some days later. Why then does that song that keeps on playing there start the moment he arrives - it's never part of the way through, it starts when he comes into shot.
Correction: He doesn't always arrive at the beginning of the song - In the first two Groundhog Days, the same time passes between the time he wakes up and the time where he's at Gobbler's Nob. At the third Groundhog Day, he rushes towards Gobbler's Nob, therefore the song starts to play when he's in the MIDDLE of Gobbler's Nob, not when he enters it. Every time the song begins when he's in different parts of the knob, therefore creating an illusion that it's the same day, over and over again.
Corrected entry: The scene where the three older women have a flat tire, Phil keeps jacking up the car, but in the shot where you look at the ladies the car is not getting any higher.
Correction: Anyone who has ever used an older style "jack" like the one that is shown can tell you it takes a good amount of time to raise the car with one. The shot from inside the car with the ladies only last about 10 seconds, hardly enough time for Phil to pump the jack a few times, let alone raise the car enough so that you notice it rising against the surrounding background.
Corrected entry: There are three shots where Phil talks to Rita at the bar. In the first two shots, the straw in the glass is pointing to Rita, while in the third it is straight up.
Corrected entry: In one shot Phil encounters Nancy Taylor at the pavilion at Gobblers Knob. The same view of the pavilion can be seen in the shot when Phil arrived at Gobblers Knob the first time, and again in a later shot of the same view, both times Nancy was not standing there.
Corrected entry: It only takes around 2 seconds for the piano student to stop playing, get her coat and books and be kicked out of the house.
Correction: First off, it's not exactly two seconds but is very quick. It's not likely her stuff would have been spread all around but in one place so getting out quickly was only a matter of the teacher getting her and throwing her out. Secondly that's the joke, Murray's character has just offered her a huge amount of money for lessons and she suddenly has no problem in throwing the student out as quick as can be.
Corrected entry: After the mayor says that there will be six more weeks of winter, Phil (the actor, not the "large squirrel) says "3,2,1." When he gets to about 2, it goes to a shot of him through the camera. The camera says "record" even though technically, they haven't even started recording.
Correction: This is normal. The reason an anchor counts down like that even though they are recording is so that when the recording is broadcast, the producers will know when to start the feed. Also, this ensures there is no time lag between the anchor counting down to "one" and the cameraman starting the camera recording.
Corrected entry: When Bill Murray exits the bed and breakfast on the first day, you'll notice that his later piano teacher is walking towards Gobbler's Nob. The second day, a different amount of time goes by between the time Bill Murray leaves the bed and breakfast and sure enough, the same people are walking towards Gobbler's Nob, including the piano teacher. Did they all adjust their own personal schedule for Phil Connors?
Correction: As Mr Connors states, he has no idea how or why he is repeating the same day over and over. Whether he is a god, or it is God or Father Time or some other force making it happen. Whatever force is making him repeat his day over and over should have no problems rearranging other people's schedules so they run across Phil's path.
Corrected entry: In one of the scenes when the German dressed waitress is carrying beers, her clothes are different from one scene to the next.
Correction: No, they aren't. In the first scene we see her in a grey dress and white blouse, and in the next scene we see her with the same outfit with a white fringe on the hem of her skirt. But - in the first scene the shot is tighter and we never see the hem of her skirt, we don't see where the fringe is and so it only looks like a mistake when we see it.
Corrected entry: At the end, in the bar, we see Larry trying to impress Nancy, who makes an obvious effort to get away from him by declining an invitation to see the inside of his van, saying she's going in to the party. He starts to follow when Rita comes up and he stops to talk to her. Instead of using this opportunity to escape, Nancy comes back to stand beside Larry. This makes no sense at all, except as a way to tell Rita that Phil was already inside at the party.
Corrected entry: When Phil steals the car with the Groundhog in it, he jumps into the car on the driver's side with the mayor standing by the passenger side, having just put the Groundhog into the pickup. When the camera cuts to Phil driving off, the mayor is now standing on the driver's side.
Correction: When the man sees Phil get into the truck, he runs around the truck to stop Phil. This can be noticed in the level of his voice in the mic and he is running up to the door of the truck as Phil takes off.
Corrected entry: In the middle of the film, where Bill Murray is trying to convince Andie Macdowell that he's a god, he introduces them to "Debbie Klaiser and her fiancé, Fred." At the end of the film, after they've gotten married, he introduces them as Debbie and Fred Klaiser. So did he take her name in marriage, or is this one of those places where siblings marry?
Correction: While interesting I don't see why this is a mistake instead of an unanswered question. Maybe the doubts they were having were over the name changing and that's how they worked it out? It doesn't seem that far out to me that they took her name as their married name.
Corrected entry: When Phil is driving on the railroad tracks in the evening, the weather is clear and it is not snowing. Later on in the film, Phil is dancing with Rita in the park at around the same time of night and it is snowing. There was no way for Phil to have affected this - the weather should be identical every day.
Correction: Just because it's approximately the same time doesn't make it exactly the same time. It is possible for it to snow for very short periods of time.
Corrected entry: There is a part in the story where Phil destroys his radio every morning. It then shows, next morning, the clock changing from 5:59 to 6:00. If, as Phil says later on in the film, the time loop starts at EXACTLY 6:00, then how would the radio be mended for 5:59?
Correction: That is because he helped all those people out on that exact Groundhog Day, he may have helped them on seperate days as well, but continued to do so each other Groundhog Day.