Continuity mistake: Jenko and Witten confront a guy creating a commotion in a market. The felon runs past them out to the sidewalk where, somehow, the two cops are waiting and grab him.
Character mistake: Officer Rachel Witten tells Eddie the gun she has belonged to her dad when he was on The Job. In episode 15 of season 8 Gormley tells Frank that Witten's dad was a FDNY Battalion Chief and her uncles were police officers. In episode 12 of season 9 Officer Witten's dad Sgt. Scott Witten speaks to Frank about being on The Job. It's unlikely and not normal for someone to become a firefighter after being a police officer or vice versa or do both jobs.
Answer: The Seal of the City of New York.