My Doctor has a Cow Puppet - S1-E22
Revealing mistake: When Rose scares Charlie, he bangs into the wall and the entire wall moves.
Continuity mistake: When Charlie goes into Jake's room and finds all the seagulls, they are projected. There is one right at the front that is very obvious.
An Old Flame With a New Wick - S1-E18
Continuity mistake: When Charlie and Bill are drinking beer at the table in the bar, the level of beer in Charlie's bottle varies from shot to shot.
Round One to the Hot Crazy Chick (1) - S1-E15
Continuity mistake: In the scene where the the 'hot chick' is smashing her psychiatrist's car with the baseball bat, a window is already smashed in one shot before we see her smash it in the next. (00:01:35)
Ate The Hamburgers, Wearing The Hats - S1-E17
Continuity mistake: As Judith is driving Jake home, you can see the fringe of his hair while he is still wearing his beanie. The next shot of him, the beanie is now covering the fringe.
Camel Filters + Pheromones - S1-E12
Continuity mistake: In the scene where Charlie and Prudence are talking about Berta, the amount of soap on Prudence's stomach changes throughout.
Revealing mistake: When Charlie and Jake are at the supermarket Jake tells his uncle to switch milk brands, and when Charlie puts the Dairy Farm 1/2 gallon milk carton back on the shelf it wobbles easily back and forth, revealing it's actually an empty carton.
Round One to the Hot Crazy Chick (1) - S1-E15
Factual error: When Frankie throws her pills out of the car, she reaches into the center console to open the window. The Jaguar Charlie is driving has its power windows in the door, a place she couldn't reach from her position.
Did You Check With the Captain of the Flying Monkeys? - S1-E6
Continuity mistake: When Alan is on the balcony talking to Evelyn, a shot is shown from inside the house. Alan turns away from Charlie and puts his left hand on his hip. The shot changes and Alan's left hand is now in the air and then he puts it on his hip again.
Continuity mistake: When Alan first meets Rose, she eventually says "He (Charlie) has a very musky scent" with her head turning to look at Alan. When the camera cuts to Alan, he says "uh huh" and Rose is all of a sudden looking straight ahead. (00:10:40)
I Can't Afford Hyenas - S1-E14
Continuity mistake: After Berta tells Charlie he owes her $74 for groceries, she walks to the table and says 'funny story' with Charlie facing the coffee machine with his head facing towards it. When the camera cuts to another angle, Charlies head is all of a sudden in a different position with no time to have made the move. (00:01:50)
Continuity mistake: While Evelyn is at Charlie's asking Alan if he's considered that there may be another man at Judith's "shacking up with her," Evelyn is wearing a blue 2-piece skirt suit, but in Charlie's close-up Evelyn's wearing a white suit with a red floral pattern when she's standing in front of Charlie, at the left side of the screen. (In the original pilot Evelyn is played by Blythe Danner wearing the floral suit, but she had to back out and was replaced by Holland Taylor, who's wearing the blue suit).
Continuity mistake: While Alan's sitting on the couch, Evelyn's talking to Alan "helping...through a very difficult time," and in the shots facing Alan all of the books on the table behind him, and also the books on the couch's side table keep changing - not just their position, all the books actually become different books. Additionally, in the shots facing Charlie, the books beside the chair and the books/CDs/DVDs on the bookcase change as well.
Answer: That would be "Corey's Been Dead For an Hour" in season 4, episode 9.
Super Grover ★