Shoes, Hats, Pickle Jar Lids - S5-E9
Revealing mistake: When Charlie is in the Ferrari, his gets a call from Teddy. When Charlie brings the iPhone to his ear and talks to Teddy, you can see that the iPhone is upside down showing that no one actually called his phone.
Dum Diddy Dum Diddy Doo - S5-E3
Other mistake: When Jake is sitting on the couch talking on the phone, he says out loud "we were on a train in a tunnel?" etc, Alan has not walked into the house yet, therefore could not hear Jake's phone conversation. However when Jake walks past Alan and continues talking on phone, Alan states "at least he isn't the tunnel." Alan was not inside at the time of this conversation, so it makes no sense that he would have heard Jake say this.
Help Daddy Find His Toenail - S5-E6
Revealing mistake: When Judith slams her door the wall wobbles. (00:17:30)
Help Daddy Find His Toenail - S5-E6
Revealing mistake: When Charlie reads the paper after the banquet the text is all the same, just repeated. (00:16:20)
Rough Night in Hump Junction (aka His Ugly Bundle) - S5-E15
Continuity mistake: When Charlie is with Mia and her father comes in, she's saying: "Daddy, this is Charlie, remember I told you about him." Back when Mia and Charlie were dating, he actually met Mia's parents at least twice.
Kinda Like Necrophilia - S5-E10
Continuity mistake: As Alan runs away screaming about betrayal, Berta begins to pour Charlie a cup of coffee. Charlie's first two or three fingers are hooked through the handle of the cup. The shot changes and Berta is still pouring but now Charlie's index finger is alongside the rim of the cup.
Chosen answer: Alan might have thought the bra was too fancy to belong to a regular woman, "I'd love to meet the girl who filled this", he says. He assumed it was one of Charlie's many women.
Eyexpress333