Continuity mistake: When the boat is caught in whirlpool and is being pulled down, there is a shot of the penguin and a bear holding on to the helm. The penguin has symbol on his tummy (which he doesn't get until the end of the movie). (00:36:00)
Continuity mistake: During the movie, the small red hearts on the Care Bears sides disappear and then reappear again between shots. This is most noticeable when Secret Bear and Friend Bear meet Kim and Jason in the park at the beginning.
Revealing mistake: When Tenderheart Bear confronts Nicholas in the Cave, the light of fire Nicholas has lit casts a shadow of Tenderheart Bear on the wall of the cave. However, when Tenderheart Bear moves his arms, the shadow stays the same.
Continuity mistake: When the evil spell takes over the tree in the Forest of Feelings, Swift Heart Rabbit bites though the branches of the trees to free the Care Bears. Friend Bear is a light orange colour, but when Brave Heart Lion catches her she is pink. (00:40:40)
Continuity mistake: When Tenderheart Bear is in the trailer watching Nicholas and Fetuccini from the doorway, notice the wall below Fetuccini's left hand as he speaks: it's plain, flat pieces of wood. But when Tenderheart is suddenly forced to hide beneath the desk, he spots a large hole in the wall through which he can see Nicholas. It shouldn't be there at all since the adjacent wall on the opposite side had no visible holes in the previous shot. (00:08:05)
Continuity mistake: While Grumpy and Good Luck Bear are in Care-a-Lot putting finishing touches on the broken rainbow rescue beam, a cloud quake ruptures the floor beneath their feet and scatters debris all around. After the quake recedes, Grumpy shoots Good Luck Bear an astonished look and, at this point, bits and pieces of the ceiling are visible on either side of the floor's seam. But in the next shot when they both turn their heads to the caring meter outside, no pieces appear anywhere. (00:58:45)
Continuity mistake: When Nicholas opens the door to reveal that Fetuccini has been possessed by a sleeping spell, a top hat and cape are visible, hanging from their own hooks on a nearby coat rack. But soon the evil spirit convinces Nicholas to perform magic tricks on Fetuccini's behalf. Once he reaches over to grab the hat and cape, they are suddenly hanging by the same hook. (00:17:05 - 00:18:20)
Continuity mistake: When Grumpy Bear is making final adjustments on the rainbow rescue beam, Good Luck Bear indicates an alarming drop on the caring meter outside. Suddenly a cloud quake occurs and the meter's gauge vanishes. As the quake settles, both of them look outside to see the gauge intact once again. (00:58:35)
Continuity mistake: In the song "It's Great to Be in the Care Bear Family," the Care Bear Cousins finally obtain their tummy symbols. However in a following shot Playful Heart Monkey is drawn without a symbol, even though he had only just obtained it.
Continuity mistake: After Nicholas casts his final spell over the cauldron, the Care Bears are shown outside of the castle walls gathered around the rail carts. Share Bear and Tenderheart are sitting up front, but in the next shot they're both walking off of a different cart. (01:01:00)
Continuity mistake: After Jason takes Secret Bear's key and seals off the evil spirit's book for good, all of the Care Bears and Cousins who were watching anxiously start cheering and jumping around. At this point, notice how the whole background consists of carnival stands, tents and a ferris wheel. But once Lotsa Heart Elephant sounds her trumpet a few moments later, there's nothing in the background except for trees. (01:04:50)
Continuity mistake: Right before Fetuccini leaves Nicholas alone to clean up the contents of his magic trunk, plenty of sunlight is shining through the doorway where Tenderheart stands watching. But in the next scene where Nicholas is lighting a lamp and placing objects on the table, the doorway appears completely dark - as though it were a closet. Had Fetuccini closed the trailer's outside door, this might be justified. (00:08:05)
Continuity mistake: When Friend Bear is working beneath the hood of a cloud mobile, Secret Bear relaxes in the driver's seat. Just then, Wish Bear runs over to break some news. In the following shot she reaches out to tap Secret Bear's head, but now he's repositioned outside of the cloud mobile. (00:03:15)
Continuity mistake: When Kim and Jason are called over to the rainbow rescue beam, Tenderheart grabs Kim's hand to lead the way. Then she lets go and points her index finger, saying, "We're going to help you." Yet in the next shot Tenderheart and Kim are holding hands again. (00:23:40)
Continuity mistake: In the shot where Kim and Jason slide down the rainbow with the Care Bears during the "Nobody Cares Like A Bear" song, Tenderheart is also on the rainbow. Tenderheart is actually on Earth trying to save Nicholas from the Evil Spirit at that very moment.
Continuity mistake: During the show while the children are laughing, a boy with a blue shirt and yellow hair is shown, however after the spell is cast he gets replaced with a boy with a gray sweater and dark brown hair.
Audio problem: When Nicholas casts the spell to make the kids fight, Tender Heart says "Nicholas what have you done?" His mouth is closed when he says "Nicholas."
Continuity mistake: When the kids are shown, the shirt color of the one with the blue suspenders keeps between orange and dark red.
Continuity mistake: Near the beginning, Mr. Cherrywood performs a quick juggling act. Once he finishes, the number of red balls in either hand alternates between cuts. (00:01:00)
Continuity mistake: When Playful Heart Monkey swings down from a tree to grab Kim's ponytail, she has both hands raised in the air. From a different angle, Kim's hands are placed on the ground behind her instead. (00:28:25)
