Factual error: John cocks his Beretta 92 on his leg, (time 1:30:44), and then you find out the gun wasn't loaded (time 1:39:35). When he cocked his gun without any bullets in it, the gun would have locked the slide open. The argument that he maybe didn't pull the slide all the way back to fake it and it wouldn't lock open would be hard to do since he did it with one hand against his leg and did it with such force he wouldn't have been able to do a shorter pull. (01:30:40 - 01:39:35)
Continuity mistake: When they bring in the car crash victim (future heart donor), the victim is in perfect condition. No blood, broken bones or anything. Pretty good to have been hit by a truck. (01:32:20)
Factual error: When the donor is wheeled in for surgery to harvest her organs there are no signs of life support, no tubes, no IV, not resporator. A donor must be kept "alive" by life support or the organs will die.
Factual error: There is a scene where John Q's son whispers to him with a breathing tube down his throat. It is physically impossible to speak, even whisper, with a breathing tube.
Other mistake: At the beginning, when the woman is driving she pulls up behind a truck she wants to pass. She sticks her head out of her window to see if there is anybody coming and her hair doesn't move at all.
Factual error: In any police siege situations, it is a standard of public safety to evacuate the entire street, if not the entire city block if possible. There is always a 'buffer' zone between the public and the cordons and road blocks. These are all international givens. Yet the spectators are close enough to almost walk in the front doors of the hospital, shout opinions, read the time on Denzels watch, etc.
Other mistake: At the end, they are harvesting the donor organs. When the camera pans around the victim, she smiles. The sound effects sounds like they are cutting her chest open, although the saw is by her left arm.
Continuity mistake: When the sniper shoots at John and then he pretends to fall dead, you can see something stuck to the bottom of his shoe, but when he gets up there is nothing there.
Factual error: In the opening scene with the truck driving the road in Montana, the license plate reads 63T. In Montana the numbers tell what county the car is from. Number 1 is the biggest county in population and number 56 is the smallest. 63 is incorrect because Montana has only 56 counties.
Continuity mistake: When Denzel's son is running to 2nd base and collapses, they turn him over and there is dirt on his nose and forehead. In the next shot there is no dirt.
Plot hole: It seemed to take the police an awfully long time to get to the hospital once it was taken under seige. It seemed to take the camera man an excess of 10 minutes to realize something was wrong. After John took the camera out it was another estimated 15-25 minutes before the police came. I find it hard to believe that the police would be that slow to get to a hospital and that the camera operator would take a few minutes before phoning something in.
Continuity mistake: When John Q. gets stabbed by the young dude, you see a blood stain in his shirt. Later in the film when the sniper shoots him there is no blood stain, even though he is wearing the same shirt.
Continuity mistake: In the beginning of the movie when John and his family sit down for breakfast, in one shot, John bites into a doughnut and as the shot changes immediately, it shows John without anything in his mouth.
Answer: She says, "John Q is a good man. He is unlike the other jerk that hits his wife in the face."