Audio problem: After Mattie is told she could be a superhero, she says, "What? I'm serious!" but her mouth is not moving. (01:48:09)
Audio problem: After Cassie says the girls will be superheroes, Mattie says, "What? I'm serious!" but her mouth is not moving. (01:48:09)
Factual error: In the diner, the kids listen to/dance to Britney Spears' "Toxic," which didn't release as a single until January 2004. This takes place in 2003.
Factual error: At the diner, the trucker reads about the three girls' abduction in the Daily Bugle, with their photos, as he recognizes them. Less than 3 hours after it happened. (Cassie said she would return in 3 hours and they had already gone to the diner before she arrived).
Audio problem: Throughout the film, Ezekiel Sims' dialogue is out of sync with his mouth movement.
Continuity mistake: In the woods, Julia kneels by the fire with her sweater lying next to her. When she stands up, the way it's folded changes.
Continuity mistake: In the woods, Anya and Mattie talk about eating, and Julia looks to her left. A shot later, she is looking ahead.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2e3d5/2e3d57f8ddb5ad17f246d619a63a462f0d214665" alt="Madame Web mistake picture"
Revealing mistake: When Cassandra hits the ambulance brakes, skid marks from previous takes on the very same spot where the ambulance stops are perfectly visible.
Suggested correction: Not a mistake... that could be played off as just skid marks on the street (even though we know it's not).
Continuity mistake: When Mattie dances on the table, Anya's arm position on the counters keeps changing in every shot.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8e95c/8e95cd5ba234491e03cbbf659216d55e787995d7" alt="Madame Web mistake picture"
Other mistake: When the girls steal a cab, there are some bystanders on the curb opposite to them. A woman next to a guy with a hat points at the camera for several seconds (for it's not a plot-wise movement).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/72182/721822456609a377b0ae8d34225c1b27f0567e1d" alt="Madame Web mistake picture"
Continuity mistake: A truck crashes against an ambulance, and both stop 2 meters before where a tree is. From an aerial angle, they're both 20 meters ahead from the tree.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e26b/0e26b44b3429d117ce00da556a56bdf5be2d3da1" alt="Madame Web mistake picture"
Continuity mistake: Cassie is doing CPR on O'Neil and his head is facing upwards. Shot changes when a paramedic arrives and places a bag on the floor. Then for a brief moment O'neil is facing sideways. Shot changes to the first angle with him facing upwards and now the paramedic bag is gone.
Deliberate mistake: When the girls take out the Pepsis, the bottles keep turning around between shots so the logo is always facing the camera.
Continuity mistake: When Amaria tells Ezekiel about how her surveillance is going, her right arm is raised. A shot later, it's lowered.
Continuity mistake: In the cave, when Santiago is talking about Cassie's powers, the way his scarf ties around his neck keeps changing all the time.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0304c/0304cfa756a31b33c4fbbdfc1ada7f5d792f50ed" alt="Madame Web mistake picture"
Continuity mistake: When Mary holds her newborn baby, her left hand is on his chest. A shot later, it's under his body.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/733f6/733f67640b2f40a8f82dd26939704b92f4030a29" alt="Madame Web mistake picture"
Continuity mistake: When Santiago talks to Cassie for the first time, her notebook is in front of all of her papers. A shot later, there's a big map instead.
Continuity mistake: When Cassie meets Santiago, she is grabbing her notebook with her left hand. A shot later, she is pressing it against her breast.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1cf00/1cf0025fe6bd7d8231a89a08903ae2497551caff" alt="Madame Web mistake picture"
Continuity mistake: When Ezekiel starts the car, he grabs the gear stick and moves it forward. An instant shot later, his hand has moved backwards.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b20e7/b20e7874d8e4d212378b5d036b7bd4b5701443e0" alt="Madame Web mistake picture"
Continuity mistake: After the cab rams the diner and comes to a stop, neither the hood nor the radiator are damaged at all. When the girls run towards it, they're both damaged.