Corrected entry: In several episodes during season 5, Brooke can is seen making phone calls on her iPhone. If you look at the screen of the phone while she's supposed to be talking to someone, it is usually on the contacts page or home screen, not the actual screen that would be there were she really connected to a call.
Every Night Is Another Story - S1-E6
Corrected entry: When Peyton, Haley, and Brooke are in the car after leaving the school (where the away game was), Brooke throws her pom-poms out the window. She is shown in the car throwing one. Then you see her throw her other one out (this view is from outside of the car). Then the camera shows Brooke back in the car. She then throws another pom-pom out the window.
Correction: Brooke does throw both of her pom-poms out of the window, but the third one she throws is actually one of Peyton's.
Every Night Is Another Story - S1-E6
Corrected entry: When Lucas and Nathan attempt to steal the thugs' car they have little success since the back tire is bogged in the mud and they bail. However a few minutes later the thugs can be seen driving the same car around looking for Nathan and Lucas, but the thugs couldn't be driving the car for two reasons: The back wheel is bogged deep in the mud, and Nathan has the key to the car.
Correction: When Lucas and Nathan are in the car, they bail. Nathan does not take the keys which would able the "thugs", who are really their opponents from the game they had just played, to drive the car.
To Wish Impossible Things - S1-E18
Corrected entry: While Haley and Lucas are having a water balloon fight, Lucas is shown throwing balloons with his right arm. This is the arm he supposedly has seriously injured after a car crash. Strange how he's not in any pain.
Correction: His arm has obviously healed as he is no longer wearing the sling either. We aren't told how far into the future this episode is.
I Will Dare - S2-E5
Corrected entry: As part of his dare, Lucas gets pictures taken with Anna in a photo booth. They have 3 pictures taken in the booth together and then the last picture is her in the booth by herself. Anna cuts the pictures in half and gives half to Lucas. At the end of the show, we see that Lucas has 2 pictures of them together, and she also has 2 pictures. What happened to the picture of her by herself? And don't you only get 4 pictures in a booth?
Correction: If you do the math of what is said, it all adds up to four, Anna has two - one of her and him, one of just herself, Lucas has two - both of her and him. Three pictures were taken of both of them, one of just Anna, at the end combined they have four pictures.
How a Resurrection Really Feels - S3-E9
Corrected entry: At the end when Nathan and Haley are about to have sex in their bed you see Haley's hand. Her wedding band is on her left hand ring finger then when Nathan entwines his hand with hers, the ring is on the baby finger of her right hand.
Correction: If you watch the whole show, from series one, Haley is hardly ever seen without the ring on her baby finger - it is not her wedding band, she had it before they got married, it is even shown on the picture on the box of series one.
Correction: Actually, while speaking to someone on an Iphone, you can change the display to go to another screen while still connected to the call.