Dead from the Waist Down - S8-E11
Continuity mistake: In this episode Alan says that he gave Judith diamond earrings while out, and that she filed for divorce then kicked him out and he moved in with Charlie. However, at the start, Alan is kicked out, and it's several months later that Judith files for divorce as he receives the papers and it's a plot point in that episode (S1 E8).
Chosen answer: Alan might have thought the bra was too fancy to belong to a regular woman, "I'd love to meet the girl who filled this", he says. He assumed it was one of Charlie's many women.
Eyexpress333