Dying For Pie / Imitation Krabs - S2-E6
Continuity mistake: Mr Krabs has no eyelashes when he tells Squidward not to tell Spongebob about the bomb he ate. (00:05:01)
Dying For Pie / Imitation Krabs - S2-E6
Continuity mistake: Before Spongebob drops the pie in Squidward's face, the rock he tripped on was never there.
Dying For Pie / Imitation Krabs - S2-E6
Revealing mistake: In the episode "Dying For Pie", you can see Mr. Krabs' legs disappear when Squidward says, "But you can't pay me enough to act brotherly on that guy!"
Dying For Pie / Imitation Krabs - S2-E6
Continuity mistake: In "Dying For Pie", Mr. Krabs takes a piece of the pie, leaving a bit of the pie missing. Later that day, Spongebob pulls the same pie out of his pocket, but the pie is fully together with no pieces removed.
Dying For Pie / Imitation Krabs - S2-E6
Continuity mistake: SpongeBob makes Squidward a tear jumper and there is a shot of Squidward sighing. In this shot, we can see no-one standing around the register. In the next shot, Mr. Krabs has suddenly appeared next to it.
Answer: I believe this is the Season 6 episode "Spongicus".