The Most Interesting Man in the World - S12-E17
Revealing mistake: When Peter is attempting to sneak into the Drunken Clam whilst keeping an eye on Stewie, Peter rips out his eye and throws it towards Stewie, though his glasses are in the way of his eye. (00:03:10)
Chosen answer: It's a real song called "Elvira". Originally by Dallas Fraizer in '66, however, this version seems to be the Oak Ridge Boys cover version. However, the mega lesbians skip the verse and just sing the chorus after the opening line.
Bishop73