Pearl Harbor - S6-E3
Character mistake: Nostalgia Critic states that once Affleck goes to the war, he spends his time in "fighter jets." But while saying this, shows him in a WWII propeller powered fighter plane. (00:11:10)
Continuity mistake: Rachel confronts the Critic outside with a gun in her hands before she farts and they both start laughing. Rachel has the weapon in her left hand, but when it cuts to a shot with both of them in the frame at the same time, the weapon jumps to her right hand. (00:30:00)
Turbo: A Power Rangers Movie - S6-E22
Continuity mistake: When Nostalgia Critic is dressed in a Power Ranger suit, he talks to Zordon on his wrist watch. In shots of Zordon, he is a hologram projecting up off the watch, but in the side shots showing Critic holding out his arm responding back, the hologram is nowhere to be seen. (00:14:50)
Turbo: A Power Rangers Movie - S6-E22
Other mistake: Despite being in the Black Ranger's suit, when Critic is "beamed" back to the Command Center, his beam is red. (00:16:55)
Les Misérables: Musical Review - S6-E29
Continuity mistake: When the reviewers realise Brentalfloss is coming back, they jump of from the bed and hide the closet. In the closet, Paw still has his headphones on, however when Brentalfloss is standing next to the bed looking for the reviewers, Paw's headphones are seen on the bed. (00:21:10)
Top 11 Strangest (Yet Best) Couples - S7-E5
Continuity mistake: After Nostalgia Critic jerks his hand away from Little Kuriboh when he realises it's him next to him, there is a jump cut to a closer up of them and his left hand changes positions between shots. And also his right hand is pointing at Kuriboh but then not. (00:00:40)
Revealing mistake: When "Alice" drinks the potion and hands it to Nostalgia Critic who also then drinks it, the cap on the bottle is still on it. (00:01:20)
Continuity mistake: When Nostalgia Critic opens the door to Burton Land, the giant bottle of potion they just drank out of behind them vanishes. (00:01:30)
Continuity mistake: When Tamera knocks on the door and the "boys" are ridiculing her about being a girl and can't enter, Cool Kid says "Fuck Flowers" and they all roar in agreement. If you watch closely you can see Tamera's right hand come up on screen in the bottom right hand corner. However when it cuts to a close up of Tamera, she's gesturing with her left hand. (00:07:00)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2014 - S8-E12
Continuity mistake: After they get the their mission from Santa Christ, The Nerd and Critic step out side and look around. Nerd notes that the city looks animated and the camera cuts to a cartoon landscape of a city that they are supposedly looking at to mirror the 80's TMNT cartoon. However, they are standing next to some glass of the exterior of their building and the reflections of the real world and real city are seen. (00:02:06)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2014 - S8-E12
Continuity mistake: When Nerd is saying "Babble science babble science babble science." it is on a close up of him and he looks to the right of the screen. It cuts to a wide shot of him next to Critic and suddenly he's looking to the left towards Critic. (00:08:40)
Fantastic 4 Rise of Silver Surfer - S11-E37
Revealing mistake: When Rob grabs Critic and Malcolm and shoves their heads out the door to see that the world is on fire, both before and after it shows the clip of a city burning you can see in Malcolm's sunglasses the reflection of the perfectly fine and normal suburban street. But they should be looking at a burning city. (00:01:30)
Continuity mistake: After the monsters are introduced and Nostalgia Critic mentions their accountant, it shows the accountant sitting at a computer with the monsters behind him. Jason Voorhees is directly behind the accountant and his arms are down at his sides. But each time the camera cuts to a close up of the monsters, he's hands are up with his machete, but then down again each time the accountant is shown. Also between each shot, Hannibal Lecter moves closer and further away from Jason, and Jigsaw keeps vanishing from in front of Hannibal each time. (00:02:25)
