Continuity mistake: When Audra takes lemonade to Will inside the place where he's working as a forger, the pitcher has a liquid which is the true color of lemonade and there's not much left in the pitcher...less than 1/4 of what it could hold. When she comes out of the building, it has the color of iced tea and there's almost half a pitcher of it, which is way more than there should be.
Last Train to the Fair - S1-E30
Factual error: At the end of the episode as the train heads towards Sacramento, above in the sky are jet vapor trails streaking across the sky.
Continuity mistake: Nick goes to the cemetery and finds Jean Price's headstone. He walks away from the right, indicating that the headstone is on the right. He rolls on the ground and just as he starts to get up you can see a headstone to the left with the words, "Jean - Beloved Daughter" just like the one he was looking at before. (00:25:00 - 00:26:00)
Continuity mistake: When Joshua was breaking the horse his hat fell to the ground, change of camera to those watching and then back and his hat is back on. The shot change to watchers again, then back, and his hat is back on the ground. This happens a few times.
Factual error: A scene near the beginning of the episode shows a man talking to a crowd holding a Peace dollar. Peace dollars were not in circulation until 1921, and I believe that the setting for this series is around 1880.