Question: In the timeline where Evan and Kayleigh were in college having a good life, where was Lenny? Why wasn't he there? Chase Gwack
Answer: Lenny was probably not their friend anymore when they became part of the college fraternity and he didn't. He would probably respond to them like Thumper did.
lionhead
True. Plus when I think about it, in the original timeline Lenny didn't grow up and was still living with his mom so thought that's where he was.