Annabel Keeley

28th Jul 2013

Supernatural (2005)

In the Beginning - S4-E3

Corrected entry: In the scene when John is talking to Mr. D in the diner, Mr. D tells John to "say hello to your old man for me." It is later revealed in season 8 that John's father left them when he was young. This is a mistake, unless Mr. D is referring to John's grandfather (unlikely). (00:04:40)

Correction: It's never mentioned what happened to John's mother. She could have remarried, and so it could be John's stepfather being referred to.

Annabel Keeley

A stepfather is the only explanation that would keep the canon consistent (other than Mr. D referring to John's maternal grandfather, or even to John's mom given that The Winchesters shows her to have been a rather tough mechanic), but out of universe, the writers almost certainly just forgot about this line.

19th May 2014

Supernatural (2005)

Correction: This is an error with Netflix, not the show itself. The subtitles on the DVD say Cantonese.

Annabel Keeley